What do you think of when you hear the word “apocalyptic”? Perhaps you imagine a post-nuclear world marked by conflict between rival groups. One could describe the world of Mad Max: Fury Road (Miller, 2015) in those terms. If you’re a fan of the Final Fantasy series, the word might bring to mind images of Kefka destroying the world in Final Fantasy VI (Square, 1994).

Lorenzo DiTommaso (2024) notes that “Apocalyptic is a term with many meanings” (p. 5). Scholars have approached it in several ways. Norman Cohn emphasizes the expectation of a violent upheaval of the social order at the end of time. Stephen O’Leary and Greg Carey focus on apocalyptic rhetoric, which Carey calls “apocalyptic discourse.” John J. Collins emphasizes the literary genre of the apocalypse (DiTommaso, 2024, p. 5). In DiTommaso’s summary, Christopher Rowland defines apocalyptic as “the revelation of heavenly mysteries” (DiTommaso, 2024, p. 5).

In English, the word “apocalyptic” can evoke visions of global catastrophe or mass destruction. It may therefore come as a surprise that the underlying Greek word, apokalypsis, means “revelation” or “uncovering.” Collins (2002) traces the word’s catastrophic connotations to its use in the final book of the New Testament, the Apocalypse, also known as the Book of Revelation (p. 1).

If you grew up in an evangelical household, you are probably familiar with the apocalyptic imagery of the Book of Revelation. It has inspired the Left Behind series (LaHaye & Jenkins, 1995) and countless sermons about the end of the world. In examining the apocalyptic worldview, Collins (2002) writes:

Life on earth is shaped by supernatural forces, which are both good and bad. The course of history is determined in advance, although individuals still have some choice as to where they stand. There will be a divine judgment to reward the good and punish the wicked, and this judgment will have its effect not only on the last generation but also on the individual dead. (p. 7)

Collins (2002) contrasts this worldview with the strand of biblical religion represented by Deuteronomy (p. 7). That contrast matters because, in much of the Hebrew Bible, the righteous and the unrighteous share the same fate in death. The Book of Daniel offers a possible departure from this view by envisioning the dead rising to face different outcomes. In Shades of Sheol, Philip S. Johnston notes, “Both the lack of obvious religious rites at burial and the lack of interest in graves confirm that Israelite life and faith were centered on the present life and relating to Yahweh in the here and now” (Johnston, 2002, p. 65).

Divine judgment that rewards the righteous and punishes the wicked is thus one idea found in Jewish apocalyptic literature of the Second Temple period. In this post, I’ll compare and contrast Jewish apocalyptic thinking with similar ideas expressed in the Native American Ghost Dance movement.

Scholars have long debated when the Book of Daniel was written. Some defend the traditional sixth-century BCE date (Miller, 1994, pp. 21–43), while others place the book’s final form in the second century BCE, during the Maccabean era (Collins, 1993, pp. 23–24; Goldingay, 1989, pp. 326–327). I find the case for the second-century date more convincing. For this comparison, I’m interested in what Daniel 12:2 says about resurrection and judgment.

Daniel 12:2 describes many of the dead awakening, some to everlasting life and others to disgrace and everlasting contempt (New American Standard Bible, 2020, Daniel 12:2). As Collins (2002) points out, the resurrection is selective (p. 112). The very good and the very bad are raised to receive their respective rewards and punishments.

This partial resurrection, in which some are raised to disgrace and everlasting contempt, can be read as a way of imagining justice for those who suffered under the persecution of Antiochus IV Epiphanes (Collins, 1998, p. 88).

Carol A. Newsom compares Daniel 12:2 with Isaiah 26:19, where the dead rise and those who lie in the dust are called to awake and shout for joy (New American Standard Bible, 2020, Isaiah 26:19). Newsom and Breed (2014, p. 362) read the verse as potentially expressing hope for an actual resurrection in the context of God’s judgment of oppressors and deliverance of the people. On that reading, it parallels Daniel 12:2. Jewish apocalyptic thought in this scenario offers hope that God’s people will find deliverance after death and that those who wronged them will face judgment.

In the Testament of Gad, a text associated with the Second Temple period, God forgives those who repent and reserves the unrepentant for “eternal punishment” (The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, n.d., Testament of Gad 7:5). Michael L. Leno (2013, p. 49) argues that the Testaments reflect a more traditional Hebrew understanding of human nature, so references to fire and eternal punishment can carry meanings other than the eternal conscious torment associated with later Christian ideas of hell.

Other Jewish apocalyptic texts describe the suffering of the wicked after death. One example is 1 Enoch, a work made up of several sections. Its heavenly tours illustrate Christopher Rowland’s emphasis on the revelation of heavenly mysteries (DiTommaso, 2024, p. 5). The use of an ancient figure such as Enoch as a pseudonymous author also allows a writer to present events already in the past as if they were still to come, giving the impression that they were determined in advance (Collins, 1998, p. 64). In one otherworldly tour, Enoch sees separate places where the spirits of the dead await judgment, including places for the righteous, the wicked, and sinners who were killed (Collins, 1998, p. 55). Jewish apocalyptic literature is diverse, but one theme that emerges is punishment after death for the unrighteous, including those who wronged God’s people, and reward for the righteous.

When we examine the Ghost Dance, we can see some similarities with Jewish apocalyptic thought. Bernard Barber (1958, pp. 512–513) describes messianic movements as announcing the imminent arrival of a golden age ushered in by a messiah. He notes that twenty such movements had been recorded in the United States before 1890. Barber also describes a return to earlier traditions and a rejection of customs associated with foreign influence. I find this interesting because it offers a point of comparison with the interference of Antiochus IV Epiphanes in Jewish religious practices during the Maccabean era. The association of the Jerusalem sanctuary with Olympian Zeus was offensive to Jews who opposed these changes (Fitzmyer, 2007, p. 62). Some Native American movements likewise sought to restore earlier traditions and reject foreign influences.

Thornton (1986, p. 13) discusses Hittman’s account linking the rise of the Ghost Dance to land loss, illness, and starvation. Railroad expansion contributed to the severe depletion of the buffalo on which the Sioux depended. Settlers also took over their remaining hunting grounds, contributing to the conflict associated with Custer’s campaign and to massacres of Sioux people (Mooney, 1965, p. 70).

The Jewish texts discussed here and the Ghost Dance movements emerged from particular social and historical conditions. Wodziwob, a Paiute man, started the 1870 Ghost Dance movement after entering a trance. He began to spread the idea that the earth could become a paradise for Indigenous people and that white settlers would disappear (Thornton, 1986, p. 1). His followers carried the movement to other tribes. Another theme was the return of animals and fish and the promise of abundant food (Thornton, 1986, p. 3).

Around 1890, a Paiute man named Wovoka entered a trance. According to Martin (2001, p. 85), Wovoka told anthropologist James Mooney that he saw God and people who had died long ago. Wovoka urged people to do good, treat one another well, and live peacefully with white settlers. His version of the Ghost Dance led some to describe him as a savior. He believed that the dance would bring the dead and the living together in a new world and that this change would come soon (Martin, 2001, pp. 89–90).

Both the Jewish apocalyptic texts discussed here and the Ghost Dance accounts express hope that the world as people knew it would soon give way to a world free of suffering. One difference concerns the fate of those seen as responsible for that suffering. Some Ghost Dance accounts envision white settlers disappearing from the earth and leave their fate after death unspecified (Thornton, 1986, pp. 1–3). Several of the Jewish texts discussed here explicitly imagine the wicked facing punishment after death.

I want to conclude by emphasizing that I in no way think that Jewish apocalypticism influenced the Ghost Dance movement. However, I find it interesting that two movements centuries and continents apart created similar ideas. These two movements are not exact parallels, but it is interesting to examine these through the lens of the anthropology of religion.

References

Barber, B. (1958). Acculturation and messianic movements. In W. A. Lessa & E. Z. Vogt (Eds.), Reader in comparative religion: An anthropological approach (pp. 512–515). Row, Peterson.

Collins, J. J. (1993). Daniel: A commentary on the book of Daniel. Fortress Press.

Collins, J. J. (1998). The apocalyptic imagination: An introduction to Jewish apocalyptic literature (2nd ed.). Eerdmans; Dove Booksellers.

Collins, J. J. (2002). Apocalypticism in the Dead Sea Scrolls. Taylor & Francis.

DiTommaso, L. (2024). Apocalyptic and apocalypticism, traditional and secular. In L. DiTommaso, J. Crossley, A. Lockhart, & R. Wagner (Eds.), End-game: Apocalyptic video games, contemporary society, and digital media culture (pp. 5–27). De Gruyter.

Fitzmyer, J. A. (2007). The one who is to come. Eerdmans.

Goldingay, J. E. (1989). Daniel. Word Books.

Johnston, P. S. (2002). Shades of Sheol: Death and afterlife in the Old Testament. InterVarsity Press.

LaHaye, T., & Jenkins, J. B. (1995). Left behind: A novel of the earth’s last days. Tyndale House Publishers.

Leno, M. L. (2013). Hell under construction: The fate of the wicked in Second Temple Jewish literature. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.

Martin, J. W. (2001). The land looks after us: A history of Native American religion. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780195145861.001.0001

Miller, G. (Director). (2015). Mad Max: Fury Road [Film]. Village Roadshow Pictures; Kennedy Miller Mitchell; RatPac-Dune Entertainment.

Miller, S. R. (1994). Daniel. Broadman & Holman.

Mooney, J. (1965). The ghost-dance religion and the Sioux outbreak of 1890. University of Chicago Press.

New American Standard Bible. (2020). The Lockman Foundation.

Newsom, C. A., & Breed, B. W. (2014). Daniel: A commentary. Westminster John Knox Press.

Square. (1994). Final Fantasy VI [Video game].

The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs. (n.d.). Sefaria. Testament of Gad 7:5

Thornton, R. (1986). We shall live again: The 1870 and 1890 Ghost Dance movements as demographic revitalization. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511752735

Leave a Reply